patching...
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

Column: Curb Sick Pay for Public Workers

Teachers, cops, others can bring home big bucks by banking unused time.

 

Last week at the New Jersey League of Municipalities convention, Gov. Chris Christie called for an end to accumulated sick leave payouts for public workers.

If only!

Parsippany again became a poster child for a Christie reform, as he has cited the huge payouts police officers received in recent years.

Two years ago, one lieutenant received $317,000 on retirement for unused sick, vacation and personal days. One patrolman got $292,000. In total, at the end of 2009, four officers got $900,000 in compensation for days they didn’t use while employed.

Morristown’s current police contract limits unused leave payouts to 40 percent of a portion of the total hours accumulated. Still, after 35 years, an officer earning $90,000 could receive about $77,000 on retirement.

While police payouts tend to be the most generous, they are also rampant in teacher contracts.

For instance, the 2008-2011 Parsippany teachers’ contract provides for some retiring teachers (those hired prior to 1993) who have at least 200 unused sick days to receive a third of all accumulated days. These days are paid at the final salary, regardless of the salary at which they were earned. A 35-year teacher with a master’s degree earning $88,000 a year could walk away with a payout of almost $45,000 even if he used two sick days a year. A teacher hired after 1993 gets 20 percent of accumulated days. Note: An earlier version of this post neglected to mention the difference between payouts for teachers hired before and after 1993.

Because there are so many more teachers, these payouts really add up.

Last week, Christie’s office said New Jersey localities paid $43 million last year for unused sick and vacation leave payouts.

Such payments are rare in the private sector.

Superintendents and top school administrators used to negotiate the amount of their leave payouts but the state capped that at $15,000 beginning in 2008. A similar cap was imposed on recent hires.

Now it’s time to get rid of, or severely limit, these payouts for all workers.

The question is how.

Both parties have introduced bills taking different approaches to the issue—for instance, either setting a maximum of $15,000 for all workers or eliminating them entirely for those earning $100,000.

Democrats complain they tried to limit sick payouts last year, but Christie conditionally vetoed the legislation. In his veto message, Christie said the bill did not go far enough and sought to toughen it.

Last week in Atlantic City, Christie said capping sick payouts at $7,500 would make a huge difference and provide significant savings to taxpayers. But he would like to eliminate them all prospectively.

The courts have ruled the superintendents’ payout cap could not be applied to amounts already accrued, so the state likely cannot erase whatever workers already have accumulated based on existing contracts. That’s why it’s important for the Legislature and governor to act fast, to limit future amounts as soon as possible.

Any bill should also require that school districts make employee contracts even easier to get by posting them online on their websites.

Districts have to include certain information about administrators’ extra pay as part of their annual budgets, but there is no requirement to disclose teacher contract information in a similarly open way.

Yes, the contracts are public and people can see or get a copy of any contract by visiting requesting it from the district office. But so many other documents are online, it wouldn’t take much more than a few minutes of scanning them in and posting them to make them even more accessible.

A survey of Morris County school districts’ websites found only a handful—Parsippany, Pequannock, Randolph and Roxbury—have posted all their public employee contracts. Several others, including Harding, Jefferson, Kinnelon, Long Hill and the Rockaways, have made only administrators’ contracts, not those of teachers, available online. The majority of districts have no contracts online.

The state’s new anti-bullying law has every district posting its policy in this effort prominently on the Internet. A law limiting retirement payouts could require that all contracts be posted, as well.

Or, until the state is able to limit sick and vacation payouts, making contracts more readily available to the public might help generate a groundswell to pressure the board of education to limit retirement payouts on their own.

Colleen O'Dea is a writer, editor, researcher, data analyst, web page designer and mapper with almost three decades in the news business. Her column appears Mondays.

  • Should public employees like teachers, police officers and administrators be able to build up sick time payments over several years?

    (Voting has been closed for this question)
    • Yes. They work hard for that money, and if they don't take the time off that some of their peers do, they should be compensated.
        194 (34%)
    • No. You shouldn't reward someone just for not getting sick. It's not like most people in the private sector get this perk.
        375 (65%)
    Total votes: 569
  • Your vote will only count once. This is not a scientific poll. View Results Vote!

Roll Back Our Tax

6:42 am on Monday, November 21, 2011

My favorite subject.

Word of the year, courtesy of my favorite forum- "Ineptocracy* (in-ep-toc'-ra-cy) - a system of government where the least capable to lead are elected by the least capable of producing, and where the members of society least likely to sustain themselves or succeed, are rewarded with goods and services paid for by the confiscated wealth of a diminishing number of producers. "

Come on Hopatcong put those contracts on line so we taxpayers can see how much it's going to cost us to break those contracts if we decide to fire some one who is not producing. The one I'd like to see is the Superintendent's contract because he's making $170,000/year for sub par schools.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Michele Guttenberger

10:00 am on Monday, November 21, 2011

These are the things that never get reviewed by an outside auditor - contract deals. People commend Hopatcong for having good audit records. Yes that tells you what you spent but no auditor can tell you if the contract you signed was good deal and money spent produced anything worth value. Auditors do not show you earned value of your tax dollar. Only a citizen's audit with review of these contracts can find the fat and waste.

KA706

7:31 am on Monday, November 21, 2011

Teachers have sick pay because they don't get disability! They have to have something* if they get really sick or in a car accident. And the days accumulate as they are not used. A new teacher only has a few days to use, so basically, he/she is in big trouble if they get in a car accident because they dont have enough days accumulated yet.

Before you post something Patch, get both sides of the story. Now you're giving out biased information, just like Christie.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Roll Back Our Tax

7:34 am on Monday, November 21, 2011

Partially true. But normally any kind of car accident is covered under your car insurance policy like all of us in the private sector. If you really get sick or are disabled you do have long term disability coverage.

http://uhr.rutgers.edu/documents/persdisabilityapp.pdf

Comment_arrow

R. Swanson

8:21 am on Monday, November 21, 2011

Fine, but if they never get into that car accident, should they get paid for those days when they retire? Absolutely not. That makes no sense. In the private sector, if you don't use sick days (for those who actually get sick days - I know I don't), then you lose them. They can accrue, but when you retire they are gone.

Comment_arrow

concerned

9:14 am on Monday, November 21, 2011

Perhaps, since the real concern here, is about disability in the event of an accident. Take away all sick days, increase the pay by that same amount and pay into the same disability I pay into so when I get into an accident I can receive disability pay. Which is 2/3 of my weekly salary (at the time of the accident)> Now you have the same coverage as does the rest of the working world. Now if you don't think that is fare. Continue like you are and lets cap the amount at retirement at the same amount my, and the rest of the working world at "Maximum Benefit Amount (MBA)

The maximum benefit amount which may be paid for each period of disability is one-third (1/3) of the total wages you earned in New Jersey covered employment during the base year, or 26 times the weekly benefit amount, whichever is less."

Comment_arrow

Roll Back Our Tax

9:23 am on Monday, November 21, 2011

Let's say, You come home from work and find there has been a sewer backup in your neighborhood....and your home has sewage all the way up to your ceilings. What do you think you should do? Raise taxes to cover the debt ceilings or pump out the @#$%&!?

Here's a good pie chart just to show you how serious matters are WORLDWIDE.

http://www.marketoracle.co.uk/Article18015.html

This article was written March 19, 2010. The arrow has moved to Europe and Regions.

Not only has our federal government been irresponsible but so are the Governors of many states when arrow moves:

California
Michigan
New Jersey
Illinois

How bad are things in California and Illinois? Both states are writing IOU's to pay bills. California since 2009.

http://www.rrstar.com/news/x1968432812/Illinois-stopgap-IOUs-grew-into-business-as-usual

http://247wallst.com/2009/07/01/the-dreaded-california-iou-system-becomes-a-reality/

How bad is Michigan. You tell me.

http://theeconomiccollapseblog.com/archives/the-new-reality-for-u-s-cities-no-money-for-street-lights-roving-packs-of-wild-dogs-and-open-air-drug-markets

Here's a nice report I will share w/you on Morris County's foreclosure crisis.

http://www.scribd.com/doc/54431479/The-Scope-of-Morris-County%E2%80%99s-Foreclosure-Crisis

Look around you. Empty homes & abandoned storefronts.

Depend on the federal government?

http://theeconomiccollapseblog.com/archives/epic-failure-the-supercommittee-was-a-super-joke

Marge

7:37 am on Monday, November 21, 2011

I think Christie is going to keep taking away from teachers until we have absolutely nothing left! Give us a break already!

Reply
Comment_arrow

Roll Back Our Tax

8:21 am on Monday, November 21, 2011

Here's the reality. Over 3,856 public workers in NJ making over $100,000 per year with the first one holding (8) positions with a salary of about $320,000. Building nice pension funds. BTW...this is dated 2008.
.
http://php.app.com/NJpublicemployees/results2.php?Submit3=here

If you don't think your pension is any good in NJ move to NY state and see the ranking of the current pension funds being paid out go to this site.

http://www.seethroughny.net/PayrollsPensions/tabid/55/Payrolls/StatePayroll/tabid/69/Default.aspx?BRANCHID=15

Seems like the NYS teachers retirement system is paying out some pretty good pensions with the top one making $316,245 in PENSION per year.

NYS state salaries aren't doing to bad either...you can see them all at this site.

http://www.seethroughny.net/PayrollsPensions/tabid/55/Default.aspx

Top one there in education is making $657,970 per year in SALARY.

BTW....both states are broke and are having trouble balancing their budgets along w/46 others. But these states are in the TOP 10 of total gap as a % of funds (last column).

New Jersey$8.8 billion$2.2 billion$11 billion 40.0%
New York$17.9 billion $3.2 billion $21.0 billion 38.8%

http://www.cbpp.org/cms/?fa=view&id=711

BandannaMan

7:46 am on Monday, November 21, 2011

You don't deserve and generally do not get "breaks" in life Marge. Generally, you work for what you earn. I'm sorry but I do not consider "not being sick" work and therefore one should not be paid for "not being sick". Especially with the great teacher health plans that cost so little to help keep a teacher from becoming sick.

Reply

Nolan

7:54 am on Monday, November 21, 2011

Great idea. While we're at it let's outlaw yearly bonuses in the private sector in the Health Sector (costs us more) Finance Sector (costs us more) pharmaceuticals (costs us more) an upper tier management (reduced dividends). Private or public, in the end it's the consumer who pays for it.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Roll Back Our Tax

8:01 am on Monday, November 21, 2011

I agree Nolan. We're a Socialist country already. Let's take it one step further.

Comment_arrow

Jay

8:38 am on Monday, November 21, 2011

Private sector is the private sector. They can make or break themselves in the free market and enjoy or suffer as a result. Public sector unions can only break the taxpayers by continuing to go to the well for more and more. It's time to be reasonable.

Roll Back Our Tax

7:56 am on Monday, November 21, 2011

No wonder NJ and NY are in such a mess. People (public) work here to earn their pensions and leave here to generally retire some where else. Why? Because after they retire they don't want to pay the property taxes the rest of us are left to pay.

Part of the "me, myself and I", generation unlike the generation before us called "the greatest generation", who fought in WWII and lived through the longest recovery period after the Great Depression. What ever happened to "shared sacrifice"?

Here are the 10 worst states for retirement, with No. 1 being the lowest ranked, according to TopRetirements.com:

Worst States for Retirement....Why You Should Think Twice

1) Illinois - Poor fiscal health
2) California - Expensive, and its finances are in disarray
3) New York - Very high taxes, including property taxes
4) Rhode Island - Worst-off state in the Northeast from a financial viewpoint; high taxes
5) New Jersey - Highest property taxes in the United States; has pension funding issues
6) Ohio - High unemployment and cold winters
7) Wisconsin - High property taxes and frigid weather
8) Massachusetts - High cost of living and high property taxes
9) Connecticut Taxes Social Security and has high property taxes
10) Nevada - Foreclosure capital of the world

Reply

Jay

8:33 am on Monday, November 21, 2011

Private sector companies stopped this process looooong ago. The unused sick and vacation time is a huge drain in the bottom line. And since the taxpayers have no way of offsetting these liabilities they should be stopped. Capping the unused time is a reasonable solution and can be negotiated at the next CB go around.

Reply

V

8:58 am on Monday, November 21, 2011

I say we let the teachers keep their salaries, sick leaves, vacations, sabbaticals, perks, healthcare plans, and whatnot. Just empower the supers to fire them all at will.

Reply

Doglover

9:05 am on Monday, November 21, 2011

The information given on the amount teachers can collect is totally FALSE. There is a State cap on unused sick pay of $18,000, regardles of how many sick days one has "banked" . I don't know where Patch found a payout of $45,000 for a Parsippany teacher. On another note, if Christie and his crew keep denegrading the teaching profession, and removing the benefits, you will soon lose all of the experienced teachers, and will no longer attract bright young people into the job.

Reply
Comment_arrow

V

9:11 am on Monday, November 21, 2011

Triple Pinocchio award goes to Ms. Schilling. First, 11A:6-19.2 only applies to public employees hired in or after 2010 (the cap is $15,000). Second, under LIFO, the "bright young people" are always fired first to protect the six-digit-salaried dinosaurs. And third, it's "den_I_grated" - some teacher you are!

Comment_arrow

Roll Back Our Tax

9:31 am on Monday, November 21, 2011

Well then I guess you'll have to find a job in the lower paying private sector teaching school at one of the many TOP notch private schools.

Comment_arrow

BandannaMan

9:33 am on Monday, November 21, 2011

I'm sorry but "experience" simply does not count any more in any sector - what counts is performance and that can only be measured by the education imparted to students in regards to teaching. As far as attracting bright young people, who care whther they are bright or young, again what matters is how well they can educate students, period. And let's face it, under trhe current setup mopst "bright young" education graduates have to look out of state anyway to simply find a permanent teaching job. Making the state more financially solvent will help draw in more people and more teaching jobs, NOT sick pay leave.

Doglover

9:24 am on Monday, November 21, 2011

You don't know what you are talking about concerning teachers. The amount of payout that a teacher such as the one in Parsippany(30= years with a Master's) could collect is $18,000. NOT $45,000. I don't know where Patch found that amount, ; it simply is NOT correct. NO teacher has ever collected that amount for unused sick time. You are correct when it concerns the newer teachers; $15,000 is the amount, soon to become much lower.
Try doing the job, then you are qualified to speak about it. Apologies for the typos, they belong to me!

Reply
Comment_arrow

V

9:39 am on Monday, November 21, 2011

Ms. Schilling, please refer me to the document that caps the unused sick time payout to $18,000. I could not find such number anywhere in the law. Is it in Parsippany's employee handbook? In Montville, there's definitely no limit to it.

More to the point, while I do stipulate that teachers are exposed to a higher risk of being sick, I can't quite understand why those who are lucky to dodge the bullet should be additionally rewarded by the taxpayers. It is even harder to comprehend the idea of accumulating sick time. After having witnessed - on national TV! - blatant abuse of the sick pay by Wisconsin protestors, taxpayers are not in the mood to be generous.

Comment_arrow

Erica

7:36 pm on Tuesday, November 22, 2011

Max-in montville the teachers get $30 a day for unused sick days, with a limit of $10,000, but since you have their contract I'm sure you already read that!!

Comment_arrow

V

8:31 am on Wednesday, November 23, 2011

> Max-in montville the teachers get $30 a day for unused sick days, with a limit of
> $10,000, but since you have their contract I'm sure you already read that!!

Erica, you are correct. Both numbers are in Section 4. What you conveniently forgot to mention is that teachers are at liberty to take all unused sick days in their last year. The Board has NEVER interfered with this practice.

Tammy

9:26 am on Monday, November 21, 2011

So basically what taxpayers would like is for public employees to work for minimum wage with no health insurance, no pension, and no paid sick time. What's next? No raises? No over-time pay? I know for a fact that a town not too far from here basically "punishes" employees for using sick time. When it is time for their yearly review if they have used more than one or two of their alloted sick days their yearly bonus (yes, I know, only those in the private sector are entitled to merit bonuses) is reduced. That says to me they are encouraged to accumulate sick time. I keep hearing "private sector". We all pay for private sector benefits and perks too, just not in the form of taxes. You think you don't pay for a Walmart executive's 6 weeks of vacation per year? You sure do, it is worked into the price of the goods you buy. You think you don't pay for a Cablevision executive's premium health insurance package? Ponder that the next time your cable bill increases. All of you anti-public employee folks act like public employees don't pay the same taxes as you do. You also seem to think public employees aren't entitled to the same standard of living as those in the private sector because your taxes pay their salaries. That is just ridiculous. There is plenty of wasted tax dollars to look at before you start attacking your fellow tax paying citizens salaries and benefit packages.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Roll Back Our Tax

9:39 am on Monday, November 21, 2011

We have choices in the private sector as to insurance, cable, etc. The market will dictate the price we "want" to or "have" to pay if we want those goods or services because of competition. But lately I have been doing WITHOUT A LOT.

We don't have a choice in the public sector because I see NO competition. We're losing because they keep cutting our services to pay for pensions, salaries and health benefits. We have to pay our taxes or we lose our homes. It's a form of ransom.

Comment_arrow

R. Swanson

2:14 pm on Monday, November 21, 2011

You're analogy is flawed. Public sector workers are paid from tax revenues that support monopolistic bureaucracies. In the private sector, bonuses come from company revenues - if a company is poorly managed and my fees go up in order to pay an undeserved bonus, I can take my business elsewhere. Can't do that with state agencies. When you rely for your living on taking taxes out of peoples' pockets, you must expect to make less than you would in the private sector.

Comment_arrow

hopenchange?

8:35 pm on Monday, November 21, 2011

I think there are a lot of areas to cut some of the perks; our economy cant recover with the burdens of ever increasing taxes,utility bills, cable due to the cost of med benefits, pensions etc. Police have the best deals with regard to unused sick time and pens, life benefits etc as does the Congress, Senate, President etc. why do we pay for their health ins and pensions? Most are millionaires, even 1-termer has many perks! Most pub workers (exc cops) have to work up to 30 yrs for benefits. Police are still in the 20-25 yr range to ret with full bens, teachers & most school emps are up to 25-30 now, . State workers get more holidays off then anyone in the private sect - other then pols who get wks off for holidays & sev times per yr even when they get 0 done. Cable rates are getting out of control due to employee bens. Just like the CEO's of private companies get huge payouts; our school supers, admins of schools and towns all get pretty good payouts, same for police chiefs, pols on the State and Fed levels, some of the bens & payouts they get in a lump some - are more then the avg workers' income for years! New teachers get less pension $ for higher input, paying into medical- that is if they get tenured; the problem is those that have been in the system for 20+ yrs;know 0 abt what taxpayers pay for med benefits, pensions (if we have one) etc & don't want to know; yet the new teachers are paying the price and bringing positive changes to school districts are let go ea yr.

Jim Nasium

9:41 am on Monday, November 21, 2011

Maybe when the state pays back what it robbed from the pension systems they can have a say. Just like poker, ante up or don't play! Most public workers only get 50 cents on the dollar for accumulated sick days upon retirement. Bargained and contracted. The overtime figure which would be paid out if workers used sick time and substitutions were made somehow never gets listed in theses one sided articles!

Reply
Comment_arrow

Roll Back Our Tax

11:53 am on Monday, November 21, 2011

Jim...you can cry about the past or look to the future. Because without some fiscal responsibility, we as a state are doomed.

I hate repeating myself. but you can "raise the ceiling on the debt or pump out the sh*t"? There is one more choice..."raise taxes". Shall we do that and send NJ to the dump?

Cause the only way I see solving New Jersey's debt crisis is to "pump out the sh*t". Can't continue going in the direction we are going in and there has got to be "shared sacrifice". The problem is NO ONE wants to sacrifice.

Again part of the "me, myself and I" generation.

Cathy Amelio

9:44 am on Monday, November 21, 2011

Thank God Christie has safety cities for illegals, this way he can staff the schools and municipalities. No one wanted to work for municipalities because of the low pay. I look at wonder at the bonus and raises the private sectors gives to the employees for their performance. The public sector does not have that nor would I suggest they do, but not every public servant belongs to a union, but are being punished by the state and the residents. Always remember that these servants live in the state, pay all their taxes as well as everyone else, but they unfortunately were willing to take a job at low pay for the benefits (that they pay for).Public employees pay taxes, pay into their pension and very few have disablitity insurance because the towns they work for decided not to provide insurance that the employee could pay into. It is the mismanagement of the pension system by State Governors, who have taken billions from the pension fund that has put this subject under the miroscope. The fund was over funded in the 90's till Whitman decided to take $2.5 Billion out of the fund to balance the budget (as did her predessors), invested the fund into Enron to make up for the lack of state contributions and, there has been no contribution by the State into the fund for the last 10 years which has been a burden on the local municipal fund to pay the state retirees. No this is not the fault of the public servant, this is the fault of the politician! Give the public worker a break!

Reply
Comment_arrow

Roll Back Our Tax

10:07 am on Monday, November 21, 2011

They used to tell me I was building a dream, and so I followed the mob,
When there was earth to plow, or guns to bear, I was always there right on the job.
They used to tell me I was building a dream, with peace and glory ahead,
Why should I be standing in line, just waiting for bread?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eih67rlGNhU

rick watson

10:08 am on Monday, November 21, 2011

Morris Township, fortunately, does not have much of a problem with this because years ago, we negotiated limits on these payouts. This was before the unions began electing people to our Township Committee, so let's hope these limits will last.
Rick Watson, former Mayor, Morris Twp.

Reply

Doglover

10:16 am on Monday, November 21, 2011

Anyone who wants to check teacher sick pay payouts can go to the TPAF website and read the law. The State has a cap, and that is it. For those who are hostile about teacher benefits, I have the following advice. Get certified, get an advanced degree, and become a teacher. It is a wonderful job, that is until recently when the media, and the politicians have made teachers scapegoats for every problem in society.
And, by the way, for those who think that most teachers make three digit salaries, check the statistics. It is a very small number. Most people stay in the job for five years, and leave. The idea that is promoted by the governor and his crew that most experienced teachers are inefficient is untrue; would you want an inexperienced doctor to operate on you? As for private schools being better, know this. Anyone who fails, has poor attendance, fights, uses drugs, becomes pregnant, curses a teacher out, or assaults a teacher, guess where they go when expelled from private school? Public School. Because the Public Schools must accept everyone.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Roll Back Our Tax

10:24 am on Monday, November 21, 2011

Well we don't want to let that happen to you. There's a great private school in Pennsylvania that takes troubled and disadvantaged youths.

http://www.georgejuniorrepublic.org/home_continue.html

Comment_arrow

Roll Back Our Tax

10:34 am on Monday, November 21, 2011

BTW....I know one town that has (80) teachers making 5 digit salaries in the $80,000 plus range but I don't know of any making "3" digit salaries. I guess that would be under $1,000? I hope you aren't a teacher.

Doglover

10:31 am on Monday, November 21, 2011

Still paid for by the taxpayer. Unless we go to only educating kids who have parents who can pay for it, and the rest remain illiterate, that is the way it has to be.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Roll Back Our Tax

10:38 am on Monday, November 21, 2011

I guess you don't read very good either.

http://www.georgejuniorrepublic.org/support.html

The first Junior Republic in Freeville, New York was established in 1895, using the financial support of neighbors and friends. This tradition of giving has continued. Since 1909, Pennsylvania’s George Junior Republic has received annual gifts and capital investments to support its mission of providing disadvantaged children with the tools needed to become contributing members of society.

The generosity of individuals, corporations, and foundations has fostered both the physical and the programmatic developments of George Junior Republic. The continued support George Junior Republic receives from these friends is imperative to the success of George Junior Republic’s holding companies including George Junior Republic in Pennsylvania, Preventative Aftercare, and George Junior Republic in Indiana. Annually, these gifts help to provide more than 1,000 dependent and delinquent youth with counseling, education, and therapeutic recreation.

Roll Back Our Tax

11:13 am on Monday, November 21, 2011

Summer comments:

Well, all I know is, the young "inexperienced" teachers we've had (especially those not yet tenured) have been excellent - AGREE

The older, soon-to-retire teachers have been anywhere between verbally abusive, to awful with young children, to good-with-kids-but-poor-communicators-and-minimalists (e.g., arranging the day so they are sure not to have any work to do outside of school hours) - AGREE not all but many.

I don't know the solutions but I do know that the tenure system and unions drive this "do the minimum" behavior and changes the motivations of younger, enthusiastic teachers, to fit the mold of the public employee - AGREE

I'd love to see teachers going the extra mile, but it's rare When I have, it's typically been an untenured teacher not yet seasoned by the pressures of the union and administration, or the lack of incentives to do an exceptional job - AGREE

The superior system would reward excellent teachers with good pay but not necessarily a "job for life" (I've seen the stats -- I think it's 0.1% of tenured teachers in NJ are let go each year, and only when there are lawsuits)- or pension, neither of which are realistic in this day and age - AGREE

Here's my suggestion...run for the school board in your town. Because it's people like you who can SLOWLY change the system.

My two oldest children were school teachers before "retiring" and raising a family. They had same complaints. It should be based on PERFORMANCE not TENURE.

Reply

Roll Back Our Tax

12:07 pm on Monday, November 21, 2011

BTW...here's the link for the school system salaries. I am not trying to get on the teachers but I'd say "educators" as a whole are well paid starting at $275,000.

http://php.app.com/edstaff/results2.php?county=%25&district=%25&school=%25&lname=&fname=&job1=%25&tfm_order=DESC&tfm_orderby=SALARY

Pension funds aren't too bad either...

http://php.app.com/NJpublicemployees11/results.php?lastn=&firstn=&location=%25&countyname=%25&fundname=Teachers+Pension+and+Annuity+Fund&tfm_order=DESC&tfm_orderby=locsal

If you want to see what an agency, town or pensioner makes go to this site.

http://www.app.com/datauniverse/

Reply
Comment_arrow

V

12:20 pm on Monday, November 21, 2011

Holy cricket, my taxes pay for that BLOAT?!! And that doesn't even include job security, two-month vacations, sabbaticals, lucrative health benefits, accumulated sick leave... If these numbers reach every suburban taxpayer, it will be torches and pitchforks time.

LV Mom

12:16 pm on Monday, November 21, 2011

Teachers salaries are public record (at least in WT). I did see a list of all the teacher salaries, and most tenured teachers were over $100k, with the new teachers starting at $40k. I tend to agree with the statements that layoffs or firings should be based on performance levels, not tenure. I have personally witnessed several tenured teachers treating children badly, yelling at them, etc. (my child being one of them). This is an outrage. The principal says work it out with the teacher. No one is saying they don't work hard, however, the reality of it is that some things just aren't necessary (like huge payouts). As in my other postings, I blame this on Unions. I have worked all my life in non-union jobs and there are no "laws" that you have to be given breaks, lunch, sick pay, vacation, or insurance. I have no pension for retirement after working close to 40 years of my life, busting my butt, and still have to work (if I ever find a job) another 20 to get social security (if there is any of that left).

Reply

zelda

12:50 pm on Monday, November 21, 2011

Their salaries are no different than someone who has worked for the same employer for the same amount of years!

Reply
Comment_arrow

Roll Back Our Tax

12:56 pm on Monday, November 21, 2011

Give me facts pertaining to that because all you're doing is "pis**ng in the wind".

http://www.usatoday.com/news/nation/2011-03-01-1Apublicworkers01_ST_N.htm

Comment_arrow

Josh Dubnick

4:44 pm on Sunday, November 27, 2011

Randy's link to a USA Today article compares public sector and private sector compensation but there is no adjustment for the fact that there are a great many private sector employees working part-time or working in minimum wage jobs. In recent years, many of the lower skilled public sector jobs have been privatized. Jobs such as building and grounds maintenance are now performed by lower paid private sector workers rather than by lower paid public sector employees. In Hopatcong, several DPW workers lost their jobs when garbage collection was privatized. Some were hired by Roselle and even if the pay was the same, the DPW workers laid off were most likely the lower paid (those with the least seniority) and therefore the "average" public sector salary increased. When comparing public and private sector compensation, one must look at the whole picture and look at comparable jobs and employees with comparable education and experience. The differences are much less when you do that.

zelda

1:02 pm on Monday, November 21, 2011

Don't stand down wind then

Reply

LV Mom

1:04 pm on Monday, November 21, 2011

As for the comment to go to college, get a degree, and become a teacher, I wish I could have. I came from a dirt poor, large family, and started working as a waitress when I was 15. After graduating from high school, I worked every day of my life in a non-union job, until the birth of my child (20+ years later--at which time I was married and could afford one). I could not afford college, yet people who are not even legal citizens in this country can get an education. As stated above, there were jobs I had to work where I got minimum wage (most of the time), worked over 40 hours, did the job of many, didn't get sick time, vacation, or insurance, yet I killed myself to become an asset to society, rather than another lazy, statistic on the taxpayers payroll. I get no pension, and cannot collect social security for another 20+ years (if I can find a job before that time, and since you have to be employed in the 10 years prior to collecting), and if there is any money left (which I payed quite heftly into but am presently not entitled to). No it's not just teachers, it is everywhere including the welfare system (which was intended to help people during times of crises like we are experiencing now), not generations of child bearing lazy people, illegal aliens who get better treatment than US citizens paying into the system, etc.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Roll Back Our Tax

1:18 pm on Monday, November 21, 2011

You're right on some facts LV especially the one about "government handouts".

Even as the economy has recovered, social welfare benefits make up 35 percent of wages and salaries this year, up from 21 percent in 2000 and 10 percent in 1960, according to TrimTabs Investment Research using Bureau of Economic Analysis data.

http://www.economiccollapse.net/welfare-state-handouts-make-up-one-third-of-us-wages

We have reached a very interesting turning point in American history. More than at any other point in modern times, Americans are deeply angry about the state of the economy. In fact, it is no stretch to say that millions of U.S. citizens are hopping mad about the economic situation. Most of them don't know exactly what is wrong, and even fewer of them have any idea about how to go about fixing things, but they do know one thing. They know that they are mad.

http://theeconomiccollapseblog.com/archives/12-reasons-why-millions-of-americans-are-incredibly-angry-about-the-state-of-the-u-s-economy

Comment_arrow

hopenchange?

11:31 am on Tuesday, November 22, 2011

I am saddened to see the "hatred" people seem to have toward teachers, putting every one in the profession in one category - now I see how Hitler led the Germans to do what they did to each other and the Jews - Christie is doing it now. We all have choices; Most teachers today have gone to college for 5-8 yrs; are paying off student loans; are paying 33% to their benefits and 6% into pensions; while those already retired are doing nothing to close the gap & our gov hasn't been paying their share -something private employers aren't allowed to do. Now new teachers are making up the diff & when they retire will do so with a much reduced pension payment; will still have to contribute to retirement medical benefits and are making less money - since most have been on a pay freeze for a few yrs already- something Gov. Christie doesnt mention. I am NOT a teacher; at the time that was my choice - teachers were lowest pd employees - much less then private sector; most worked 2 jobs. No one complained on their behalf at that time. Most teachers are caring people; it isn't easy to deal with kids today; parents rarely back them up, disciipline in unheard of and mostly not allowed in public schools. I work for a Dr, he is my only boss; as a teacher you have many bosses - principal, supers, and school board, plus the parents; whose little johnny and janie never do anything wrong. Complain about the politicans' benefits - if we stopped ALL of that; we would be our way to true tax savings.

LV Mom

1:12 pm on Monday, November 21, 2011

And there are also people who work just as hard. When I started out of high school, the job I held was as a Receptionist, which meant answer the phone and greet people. Through the years it became Secretary, which was answer the phone, greet people, file, type, make coffee, take notes, etc. It then became Administrative Assistant: phone, greet, file, type, take notes, make coffee, mail, purchasing, scheduling, payroll, accounting (payables, receivables, bank reconciliation, checkbooks, taxes), and so on with a never ending list of jobs required for little pay. I have run entire companies with what I have done, other than physically going out and getting the business, but everything within. If that is not working hard, then I don't know what is. I have helped teachers out all I can with regards to my volunteering, gifts at Christmas, end of year, etc., as well as donating class supplies and don't have anything near what they get.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Doglover

1:02 pm on Tuesday, November 22, 2011

hopenchange?, You hit the nail squarely on the head, and commend you for it. LV Mom, stop whining, and get some more training; it will pay off. And, you will feel less resentful of others who have improved themselves and have more. Having a high school diploma is not anywhere near enough education to succeed in today's world in spite of the fact that you are a hard worker. Your hard work AND additional education and training will get you out of the worl of the minimum wage crowd. To do this, you will have to sacrifice your evenings, and other free time, as I did. Believe me, it is worth it!

Louis C. Hochman

1:31 pm on Monday, November 21, 2011

We've clarified a point in the column. The payouts for Parsippany teachers hired prior to 1993 are different than those for teachers hired after that year.

Reply

Doglover

1:40 pm on Monday, November 21, 2011

One last post on this. "Summers Off" is not paid time. Most teachers must find employment for the summer. You are incorrect about most tenured teachers make $100,000. Tenure has nothing to do with pay. By the way, it only political protection, not lifetime employment. Any experienced teacher who does not do the job, is rude to kids, etc. needs to be fired. If the tenure law needs to be tweeked to make this easier, most teachers are for it. The benefits teachers have were put in place to entice people to go into the job. Remove them, and most people will go into a more lucrative career. Once again, if you want to do the job, get the credentials, and do it. Most of the people who go into teaching from the private sector do not last, but you might. There are positions in the urban areas, such as Newark, where if you have the strenghth, and something to offer the kids, you might be able to make a difference. There is nothing more rewarding than a kid coming back to thank a teacher for their help or guidance. That is priceless......

Reply

james

1:55 pm on Monday, November 21, 2011

Why is this such a big deal to you people? It doesn't affect you either way. Most of u are just upset because its something u don't get. It doesn't affect u or your taxes so stop crying about nonsense

Reply
Comment_arrow

V

2:10 pm on Monday, November 21, 2011

Would you testify in the court of law that it doesn't affect our taxes?

Comment_arrow

Bronson

2:10 pm on Monday, November 21, 2011

James it does affect our taxes....who the heck do you think pays all of the salaries! The more the "perks" government workers get ---gets passed along --and just because it doesn't read tax doesn't mean its not.....like motor vehicle --everytime there an increase, extra fees....we pay.....it goes to support the work force..GET YOUR FACTS STRAIGHT

LV Mom

2:41 pm on Monday, November 21, 2011

@Doglover: Teachers are paid an "annual" salary, they are not paid by the hour. Therefore, they are paid during the summer they are off. As a non-union person, I only get paid for the time I work, not a flat salary for the year broken out into weekly or monthly payments. Also, in my town, those are the salaries the "tenured" teachers are earning. And as for firing those who should be, not too long ago during this huge teacher layoff situation in both NJ & NY, the last in, were the first out, period. That is how it is right now.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Doglover

5:15 pm on Monday, November 21, 2011

You are misinformed. Teachers are only paid for the days that they work. They are not paid for the summer, and are not paid for time off. They are also not paid for the nights and weekends spent preparing for class. This is because it is a "career", not a job. You have the two confused. Yours is a case of feeling that everyone should receive equal pay, benefits. etc. If you want these benefits, GET CERTIFIED. Go to college at night, and in your free time, like many people do. I would agree with you about eliminating LIFA, but, the situation is way too political for that. For example, prior to tenure, evey time the governor or mayor changed, so did the teachers. If it were eliminated, only those with political connections would get the jobs. BTW, most teachers HATE unions, but, in a job that is so political, it is a necessary evil. With all of this said, Christie gets on the radio and lies about lowering taxes. My taxes (yes, teachers pay taxes, too) have gone up.I doubt if yours are as high as mine. But, everything cannot be equal in a free society.

Comment_arrow

V

5:30 pm on Monday, November 21, 2011

Doglover scores a Pinocchio Award. Teachers are paid a yearly salary to perform their duties. One can easily confirm this obvious fact by looking their salaries up on the Internet.The number of hours they spend in school is, in fact, much lower than 8 hour a day, to compensate for homework, and they only work for 178 days a year, as opposed to most private-sector employees. Other off-time duties, such as running extracurricular activities, are paid separately with stipends. Teachers also have sabbaticals, a rather unique and highly valued benefit that allows them to take every 7th year off - fully paid! - to continue their education.

Motown Gentleman

3:12 pm on Monday, November 21, 2011

All of the people bitter and angry in this column will remain that way, and all those with a cavalier happy attitude will remain that way. The fact is nothing gets solved on an internet forum...EVER. In fact it has been proven most internet forum-based heated discussions will inevitably descend to someone calling the other side Nazis or Hitler. Wait for it...wait for it...

Reply
Comment_arrow

V

3:21 pm on Monday, November 21, 2011

What's the point of you being here, then? :P

Comment_arrow

Motown Gentleman

3:30 pm on Monday, November 21, 2011

To argue with people who have differing opinions and hopefully force them to see it my way...oh no wait...that's you. Booo-yah! Peace in the Middle East Max.

james

3:25 pm on Monday, November 21, 2011

Its a public forum. We do still have freedom of speech right? Or are the public employees abusing that too?

Reply

LV Mom

3:52 pm on Monday, November 21, 2011

This has nothing to do with what I don't have. It is what they continue to "want," "get," and insist they are entitled to with my "taxpaying" dollars. Private companies that pay people like me minimum wage or barely above, aren't getting it from the towns taxpayers, it is coming from those who buy their product, which has nothing to do with money directly funded with my tax dollars. I'm told if I don't like it, get another job there are plenty out there waiting for one. They have a "union" saying they can't be treated that way, and this is what they are entitled to, with money "I" pay for.

Reply

Bronson

3:57 pm on Monday, November 21, 2011

James I'm sure you voted for Corzine who now has run a company into the ground and its missing 400 million dollars......and he didn't do anything for New Jersey except line the Unions pockets including his girlfriends...so your mad because you are losing something....stop crying and join the rest of us...many who have no jobs! here's a tissue...

Reply

james

3:59 pm on Monday, November 21, 2011

Ummmmmm..........public employees pay taxes too. Private companies also give bonuses, which I don't get. Alot of private companies are closed the day after thanksgiving and I have to work........Its not fair! WAAAAAAAAAAAAAA.......

Reply

Roll Back Our Tax

4:01 pm on Monday, November 21, 2011

Don't get mad...get even. I appeal my taxes every year no matter what the cost. Last year I got $2,500 knocked off. This year I'll get another $1,000. Here's the site.

http://www.state.nj.us/treasury/taxation/pdf/other_forms/lpt/petappl.pdf

It's the best thing you can do to increase the value of your home. Then sell it and get out while there's still time. When the state or towns run out of money and there's no one left to tax, it will be the public employees taxing themselves for their pensions, benefits and salaries. That will be like the best thing that could happen. Even if they reassess, you'll be that far ahead of the next guy. If you need a tax attorney and appraiser let me know.

Reply

james

4:02 pm on Monday, November 21, 2011

Im not losing anything .. I have a job and im not going to waste my time crying about what other people have. What has christie done that personally affected you?

Reply

james

4:17 pm on Monday, November 21, 2011

Bronson thanks for the tissue. Id say thanks for my pension but the governor doesn't make that payment. He just tells u he doea

Reply

Mikey

4:42 pm on Monday, November 21, 2011

Here we are, middle class people fighting amongst ourselves and critisizing the few remaining who still have a decent benefits package. Meanwhile, the rich get richer and have a good laugh at our stupidity.

Reply

LV Mom

4:51 pm on Monday, November 21, 2011

I actually agree with something Max said! It is at our expense they have what they have. Many of us who used to be considered Middle Class, are no more, so as you stated yourself in so many words, they are the ones who continue to get richer, while the rest of us keep getting poorer.

Reply

jim conley

4:58 pm on Monday, November 21, 2011

nothin for nothin!!! every cops a criminial and all sinners are saints. mick jagger!!!!!

Reply

Mikey

5:07 pm on Monday, November 21, 2011

We can no longer afford to pay for decent benefits because our wages have been stagnant for years.

Reply

Roll Back Our Tax

5:33 pm on Monday, November 21, 2011

"As private-sector unions have withered, public-sector unions have grown dramatically. The Bureau of Labor Statistics reports that, in 2009, for the first time ever, more public-sector employees (7.9 million) than private-sector employees (7.4 million) belonged to unions. Today, unionized workers are more likely to be teachers, librarians, trash collectors, policemen, or firefighters than they are to be carpenters, electricians, plumbers, auto workers, or coal miners".

http://www.nationalaffairs.com/publications/detail/the-trouble-with-public-sector-unions

"New Jersey has drawn national attention as a case study, but the same scenario is playing out in state capitals from coast to coast. New York, Michigan, California, Washington, and many other states also find themselves heavily indebted, with public-sector unions at the root of their problems. In exchange, taxpayers in these states are rewarded with larger and more expensive, yet less effective, government, and with elected officials who are afraid to cross the politically powerful unions".

"But if states' and cities' fiscal ills grow painful enough, the unthinkable could someday become political necessity. If such a rapid recovery is not forthcoming, though, the most appealing solution will be for everyone to re-enter the real world — if only public officials and public-sector unions can be sensible enough to try".

The economy is not improving or recovering. Brother can you spare a dime?

Reply

Roll Back Our Tax

5:40 pm on Monday, November 21, 2011

continued...

Courts across the nation also generally held that collective bargaining by government workers should be forbidden on the legal grounds of sovereign immunity and unconstitutional delegation of government powers. In 1943, a New York Supreme Court judge held:

To tolerate or recognize any combination of civil service employees of the government as a labor organization or union is not only incompatible with the spirit of democracy, but inconsistent with every principle upon which our government is founded. Nothing is more dangerous to public welfare than to admit that hired servants of the State can dictate to the government the hours, the wages and conditions under which they will carry on essential services vital to the welfare, safety, and security of the citizen. To admit as true that government employees have power to halt or check the functions of government unless their demands are satisfied, is to transfer to them all legislative, executive and judicial power. Nothing would be more ridiculous.

The very nature of many public services — such as policing the streets and putting out fires — gives government a monopoly or near monopoly; striking public employees could therefore hold the public hostage. As long-time New York Times labor reporter A. H. Raskin wrote in 1968: "The community cannot tolerate the notion that it is defenseless at the hands of organized workers to whom it has entrusted responsibility for essential services."

Reply

LV Mom

5:46 pm on Monday, November 21, 2011

@Doglover: Not to "beat a dead horse" as the saying goes, but no matter how you look at it, if you are paid the salary of $100,000 a year, it doesn't matter how many days, hours, etc. you work. You get the same amount no matter what for the ENTIRE year. How you get paid weekly, monthly, etc., and how you budget that FLAT SALARY during the whole 12 months, is totally different than if I am paid "BY THE HOUR," If I work 8 hours at $10/hr., I get paid for 8 hours, period. Not $10x40 hrs. weekx52 weeks=$20,800. If I am out sick, etc. and only work 24 hours during the week, then I don't get a salary of $20,800, I get less. This is a HUGE difference in what you are saying that teachers have to get jobs in the summer to support themselves. I think not.

Reply

james

6:07 pm on Monday, November 21, 2011

My friend in the " private" sector makes over $100,000 and is getting a big christmas bonus. Its not fair!!! Waaaaaaaaaaaaaaa!!

Reply

Roll Back Our Tax

6:14 pm on Monday, November 21, 2011

The scenario that's playing out in Greece, Spain, Italy implementing "austerity" programs to combat their sovereign debt. A brief history. .

http://exiledonline.com/all-pain-no-gain-a-brief-history-of-austerity-program-massacres-disasters/

Conclusion: All pain and no gain

It's starting to occur in Great Britain now as well. All are victims of what people in Britain call “the cuts” — the government’s defunding of civil-society institutions in order to balance the nation’s books. In London, austerity means that there will be about 19 percent less to spend next year on government programs".

http://www.nytimes.com/2011/08/11/opinion/when-budget-cuts-lead-to-broken-windows.html

A glimpse into the future for the USA....

http://endoftheamericandream.com/archives/austerity-riots-a-glimpse-of-americas-future

"There are some important differences between the situation in Greece and the situation in the U.S., but there are also some important similarities. Budget cuts and other austerity measures are being promoted by the political leaders of both countries. Greek citizens have reacted very negatively to austerity plans. As budget cuts on the federal, state and local levels in the United States start to really become painful, we will eventually see the same kind of austerity riots in this country'.

Prepare...

http://www.politicalgateway.com/news/read/173353

Why???

http://www.timeline2012.net/prepare/social-economic-impacts/economic-depression

Reply

LV Mom

6:30 pm on Monday, November 21, 2011

Plus I don't know of too many hourly employees that get any kind of bonus at all. It seems that all the managment get that for saving the company money, and how is that done? By cutting the wages of those hourly people, making them pay huge fees for insurance (if they get it), and cutting jobs by giving the work to those who are already overworked.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Doglover

7:53 pm on Monday, November 21, 2011

You need to get a career, not a job, which pays hourly. You don't take it home. You want to spread the wealth around, and make it so that everyone is paid the same. You work at an hourly job, which is your choice. Get some more training, and get a better job,which means that every bit of time you put in is paid. You did not need to spend money going to college, we did. We are not putting you down. It is just that a career is different from a job. Anything extra teachers do is not covered by overtime. We just do it. Again, if you want these conditions, go to college, and do the job. Try to do it in a city like Newark, where it is a real challenge. After that, you will be singing a different tune.

Roll Back Our Tax

6:30 pm on Monday, November 21, 2011

Conclusion...

There are only three possibilities to recover from the current financial apocalypse. One is to raise taxes, however, it is not likely taxes could be raised fast enough to avoid bankruptcy or slow enough to avoid destroying the economic growth and the value of the U.S. dollar against world currencies.

Second is to have more money coming into the system than is being spent by the system. This implies reducing expenses on every level from individual to government, but also maintaining continuous economic growth. The only way to stimulate this possibility is sound fiscal management and borrowing more money, however, this only takes us further down the road of unsustainability.

Third is by divine intervention. What you say? This means forgiveness of all debt by the Federal Reserve Bank and bond holders, printing even more money, and giving it to every ailing corporation or Government, interest free? Not a plausible solution as it results in exponential inflation and an immediate collapse of the U.S. economy.

No matter how this plays out, it is a certain fact that the U.S. currency will be devalued to the point of extinction. In other words, a single U.S. dollar today may be worth only five cents tomorrow. The collapse of the U.S. dollar will go hand-in-hand with the collapse of the economy. The Amero is the currency they have planned to replace the Peso, Canadian and U.S. dollars just as they did with the Euro.

Reply

Louis C. Hochman

6:32 pm on Monday, November 21, 2011

Folks, please do your best to keep the conversation civil (even when replying to someone you feel isn't). We're glad to have a space where people can debate points they feel passionately about. But there's no need to get insulting, mean-spirited or profane. We'll delete comments that are any of those, and we'll suspend the accounts of repeat offenders.

If you feel a comment is inappropriate -- don't respond in kind. No one's going to be swayed by being insulted. Instead, hit the small link that says "flag this inappropriate," and we'll take a look.

Reply

LV Mom

6:36 pm on Monday, November 21, 2011

@James: I guess my post was removed for calling you a name. But what it said was apparantly your "friend" (probably yourself) is the one sitting behind a big expensive desk, not doing much of anything, while the rest of us hourly workers do the work for you. And my guess is you haven't seen any of the Undercover Boss tv shows, as none of them could do the job they were paying the rest of us miniscule salaries to do.

Reply

Rich Smith

9:08 pm on Monday, November 21, 2011

When I first started working in the public sector I was surprised that we do not have the short term disability that I thought was a law when working in the private sector. It was explained that the sick time accumulation was to compensate for the lack of that insurance. No question though that it is being abused. Solution: Sick time does not kick in until an employee is off for two days without pay. (If I am sick, I’ll take the hit.) Then, sick time can kick in with a doctor’s certification. We need a doctor’s note to return to work after three days off anyhow. You will see a big drop in one and two day call-out if we don’t get paid for them. As for the retirees hitting the jackpot: If we are covered by short term insurance we would not collect “un-used” time when we leave, why collect sick time when we leave? Don’t blame the unions for all of this. They only get as much for their members as they can. That’s what they are getting paid for. Nor does the fault lie with the people on the other side of the table who were too afraid to stand up to the unions. They were being paid to keep the schools open and the police on the road, and they thought this should be done at any cost. But; let’s not look for fault, look for solutions.

Reply

james

9:09 pm on Monday, November 21, 2011

Honey if I was making over 100,000 I wouldn't be involved in this conversation. And calling names just shows your character. If you're not happy in your current situation stop blaming others and change it yourself!

Reply

Jay

10:38 pm on Monday, November 21, 2011

A whole thread of whiners, totally amazing. The only person responsible for anything is the person in the mirror. Christie this, Obama that, since when was anyone in government responsible for your life? You don't like your situation? Change it, or sit there making excuses about how others are stopping you from reaching your potential. Public employees have benefits that are off the scales, private employees work harder than the imagined rich people.

I am growing tired of over educated over privileged underachieving people crying all the time. Go spend some time on the streets of Newark or Camden so you can realize what you have.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Doglover

7:27 am on Tuesday, November 22, 2011

I have "done it" in a town next door to Newark (it might as well BE Newark) for way over 30 years, so I know what I am talking about. I am not complaining; I loved it. The whiners I see here are those people who cry that they are hourly workers. Most are who are too lazy to improve their skills(not necessarily college) to improve their income and benefits. And, I would bet that none if these whining crybabies would do my job!

Roll Back Our Tax

6:28 am on Tuesday, November 22, 2011

Can't wait for the next Depression to hit....these comments will all be a thing of the past.

http://theeconomiccollapseblog.com/archives/17-quotes-about-the-coming-global-financial-collapse-that-will-make-your-hair-stand-up

"More "waves" will come after this next financial crisis. If we continue on the road that we are on, our economy will progressively get worse and worse".

"Not everyone will agree with this analysis, and that is okay. In the end, time will reveal the truth to all of us".

"Right now, we all need to get ready for the next wave that is about to hit us. A lot of people are going to lose their jobs over the next few years. Hopefully you are prepared for that".

Guns, ammo, bottled water, canned food, dry food, fuel are good starters.

Reply

james

9:45 am on Tuesday, November 22, 2011

Its raining today . Must be the public employees fault.......waaaaaaaaaa

Reply

james

10:57 am on Tuesday, November 22, 2011

What does montville have to do with hopatcong? If you people have all the answers to being a better teacher then step up and do it! Leave your desk and run a classroom for a while. I don't see any teachers telling you how to do your job......

Reply
Comment_arrow

Roll Back Our Tax

12:11 pm on Tuesday, November 22, 2011

Yes there are bigger issues elsewhere. My posts are only to inform all taxpayers in NJ

Comment_arrow

Doglover

12:49 pm on Tuesday, November 22, 2011

STATE Law DICTATES a minimum number of days STUDENTS must attend school as 180. Teachers often work other days,negotiated by contract, or on a volunteer basis. So 178 days is a violation of the law, but, I suspect it is a product of misinformation. Once again I state, if you want the same benefits, DO THE JOB! The firings depend on the superintendent; mine does not tolerate poor teachers; they are terminated, tenured, or not, as it should be. The only ones who escape this ploicy are those with political connections.

Comment_arrow

V

12:59 pm on Tuesday, November 22, 2011

No Pinocchio Award this time, as the law really requires 180 days of instruction, but nothing in the law says that it cannot be a substitute teacher.

By the way, would you mind telling us which district are you in, and how many teachers were fired from it in the last decade? If your super managed to kick out more than one lemon, he deserves a monument in his name.

Dan Grant

11:51 am on Tuesday, November 22, 2011

Private Sector workers are the Bob Cratchets of the work force. Except he was a much nicer person. They have allow their Corporate employers to rob their incomes and benefits and instead of fighting back, they have caved to higher stock prices, dividens and upper management incomes. Maybe they believe they will make it to the top one percent but the odds are against them. The proof is right in their faces in the growing income disparity. Their answer is instead of fighting for their rights and a fair benefit package they want to tear down others who have fought for those things. Every dollar taken from another middle income public employee is a dollar taken out of the little demand we have for products and services. With a reasonable multifier effect it is a blow to regaining our ecconomy. Don't be jealous of those that have joined unions, join one yourselves. You are a part of the 99 percent and you will always be a part.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Roll Back Our Tax

12:09 pm on Tuesday, November 22, 2011

Dan...like I commented before to you. As this economy tanks we'll need more Correction Officers to man the jails. If I was looking for a public job...that's where I'd apply.

Comment_arrow

Lurky Loo

12:13 pm on Tuesday, November 22, 2011

Yeah and when we all join a union we can start acting like Greece and burn the country down...entitlement mentality never ceases to amaze me. It's all about me me me instead of us us us. If you put 100 union workers in a room and said 20 of you have to go or take a pay cut, you'd be arguing which 20 should leave. Never once entertaining the possibility of trying to work things out so none of you would have to go. What's the matter, I thought you like the idea of distribution of wealth? I guess not so much huh?

Comment_arrow

Doglover

1:12 pm on Tuesday, November 22, 2011

Substitute teachers get NO benefits whatsoever. They are not rquired to have a college degree, just 60 credits. They are simply put, not teachers. They do not do lesson plans, discipline, records, testing, etc. Max, you are the typical "driveby" education "expert " who really is misinformed, sorry to say, as many people are. No offense intended. It would be the same circumstance as someone who has BEEN to a hospital thinking he/she could RUN the hospital. Because education is a political football EVERYONE is an expert. Not so with a hospital.

Comment_arrow

V

1:21 pm on Tuesday, November 22, 2011

Do you just respond in a random thread? By your logistic skills, you surely won't qualify to any private employment.

I firmly believe in two things. The first is that you are entitled to your opinion but have to keep your insults zipped up in your mouth if you want any semblance of discussion. And the second is that, unlike you, I've been teaching in three different countries - have you? What do you really know outside your union echo chamber?

Comment_arrow

Lurky Loo

12:33 pm on Tuesday, November 22, 2011

Yes James, you'll be the one crying when you have to give up all your accumulative benefits but you'll eventually get over it. ....someday

Comment_arrow

Doglover

1:38 pm on Tuesday, November 22, 2011

Your rude, uncivil comments do not deserve a response. However, YOU are the one who has been hurling insults at anyone who does not agree with you. And by the way YOU are the one who has no "logistic" skills. I doubt if you could handle my job---try an urban high school....they would eat you alive!

Comment_arrow

V

1:57 pm on Tuesday, November 22, 2011

What?! They still eat people? Why am I not surprised...

parhome

1:30 pm on Tuesday, November 22, 2011

and public employees can certainly purchase disability insurance on their own. my husband does and WE pay for it.

Reply

LV Mom

5:13 pm on Tuesday, November 22, 2011

@Doglover: Don't even go there with the Obama crap about "spreading the wealth around." That is for the people who made this whole mess, those lazy people being supported by MY hardworking tax dollars. It's the reason I can't sell the home I put $100,000 in cash down on! The Obama nonsense about everyone being entitled to the "American Dream" of owning a home. BULL! If you can never in your lifetime afford to pay for it, you are not entitled to it. Because I was unable to go to college, doesn't make me a piece of dirt! And just because, I am assuming you have a degree, that doesn't make you any smarter than me. That's just plain nastiness.

Reply

LV Mom

5:16 pm on Tuesday, November 22, 2011

@Doglover: In regards to your statement that none of us "hourly" whiners would do your job, just what job is that? With that nastiness, you certainly couldn't be one of the teachers we are discussing (oh wait, yes you could, one of the ones that needs to be removed, but can't because of the UNION).

Reply

LV Mom

5:57 pm on Tuesday, November 22, 2011

"Men who have gone to college I find to be amazingly ignorant. They don't seem to know anything." Thomas Edison - NY Times 1921

Reply

james

9:10 am on Wednesday, November 23, 2011

Looky loo, what am I giving up? Please tell the governor to make my pension payment!

Reply
Comment_arrow

Lurky Loo

9:16 am on Wednesday, November 23, 2011

Maybe you should have been asking every other Gov BEFORE Christie to make your pension payment.

Comment_arrow

V

9:19 am on Wednesday, November 23, 2011

While you're at that, ask Corzine to return your stolen investments. :)

LV Mom

9:11 am on Wednesday, November 23, 2011

@Roll Back our Tax: You are correct when you state things are going to be getting worse. However, the people who will continue to be affected are only the "hourly whiners" who are too lazy to go out and get a better education.

Reply

LV Mom

9:20 am on Wednesday, November 23, 2011

@Dan Grant: Oh, let me join the Union for Accounting, Secretaries, Cashiers, Wait Staff, Cooks, Clerks, Payroll, etc. Oh wait, I don't seem to see anything for those jobs. But God forbid there were none of us willing to do these jobs, because then there would be no companies in business without us. You all act like you're so high & mighty, but if we all went on strike, whatever your job is, it wouldn't get done.

Reply

james

9:22 am on Wednesday, November 23, 2011

You're right. But this idiot is now obligated

Reply
Comment_arrow

Lurky Loo

9:34 am on Wednesday, November 23, 2011

Where's your hate for Corzine? or Codey? or McGreevy? oh wait, they were all posturing for the unions, promising the big bucks and then sucking the state dry but you want to blame a Republican cause it's the "in" thing to do. You continue to stick up for the criminals who got you into this mess but lash at the one trying to clean it up. Yes it all makes perfect sense. To paraphrase you James, Waaaaaaaaaa. Get over it, your time of take take take, is gone gone gone. It's all over but the crying.

james

9:24 am on Wednesday, November 23, 2011

Max get your facts straight. Whitman made the bad investments and started the mess

Reply
Comment_arrow

V

9:34 am on Wednesday, November 23, 2011

Lay off koolaid and get your morning coffee. Does "MF Global" name ring a bell to you? For four years, New Jersey was run by a criminal.

james

9:38 am on Wednesday, November 23, 2011

Yea okay ! Like I said it started way before him. And they're all criminals ......

Reply
Comment_arrow

V

10:04 am on Wednesday, November 23, 2011

Let's make a distinction between lousy governors such as Whitman and criminal scum like Corzine. I hope he shares a cell with Bernie Madoff and a 6'4" guy called Bubba-Joe who shares McGreedy's tastes.

james

9:40 am on Wednesday, November 23, 2011

Again, tell me what's over. I have a job and what is crusty cleaning up? How has he personally helped Looky loo?

Reply
Comment_arrow

Lurky Loo

9:53 am on Wednesday, November 23, 2011

Your never-ending sick days for one. Your never ending raises for another and all the other changes Sweeney and Oliver made to public unions, not just crusty as you so eloquently called him. It's so hard to take you for anything other than an overgrown kid who had his lollipop taken away as you can't seem to follow a thread or even read a person's name correctly but I didn't expect much from a union lap dog anyway. Your great for name calling and throwing fits, but so is my 2yr old. I think you need a time out! lmao...have a great day james and Happy Thankgiving.

LV Mom

9:44 am on Wednesday, November 23, 2011

This whole thing has gotten way of the track it was originally about, which is paid, accumulated, sick time upon retirement, not how much teachers make, what they are paid, or anything else. And since I am a single parent, Doglover, you can certainly come to my home every evening to watch my child (without pay) while I go to school to get a "better" education. In the real world I Iive in, people who have a piece of paper aren't necessarily smarter than I am (this is a FACT from experience). You can put me up against anyone with an Accounting degree, and I guarantee you I know AS MUCH, IF NOT MORE, than they do (something I have been told on many occassions when applying for jobs--yet only the ones with that piece of paper get). So this means I should be treated like dirt? I don't think so. During my ex's experience taking college classes in the "computer" industry, sorry to say, but he got fed up with it as he had MORE knowledge than the teacher who he had to correct on many, many, occassions. And I've seen how all those people with degrees and education could do the jobs that the rest of us are paid very little to do. One of the most shocking, the CEO of Great Wolf Resorts couldn't even function as a waitress! All those big wigs were either "fired" by, or wouldn't be hired by, those of us "under educated" people to do our jobs. And from what I've seen, a majority of people with those high earning degrees never pay their loans back!

Reply

james

10:03 am on Wednesday, November 23, 2011

Im not the one crying. I have plenty of sick days to use. I have no intention of getting paid for my sick time. That's there for me to use. And you have yet to tell me what the governor has done that personally affected you. It seems the only ones having fits are the ones like you who are Pissed that people get things that you don't.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Lurky Loo

10:21 am on Wednesday, November 23, 2011

Your so totally missing the point sweetie! It's not about what I DONT have, its about you constantly taking what we no longer have. Your not willing to cut back or to take less like the rest of us have had to do and you forget the most important part of all. WE pay for it. So by Sweeney and Oliver making changes to the unions gives me more money in my paycheck as it's no longer going to you. For the record, as long as my taxes pay for all your benefits I can cry, scream and yell all I want, just sayin' ;) Public Unions should stop biting the hands that feed them as we may not be so willing to take our hands out of our pockets for them any longer.

LV Mom

10:15 am on Wednesday, November 23, 2011

James, it seems you and Doglover just don't get it. This has nothing to do with people wanting what someone else has. What is wrong with you people? It has to do with getting paid for accumulations of days people aren't sick. I am happy for them that they are lucky enough not to get sick. If this is such a big issue, than maybe they should start taking days off and use it up. It just seems to me that it is taken advantage of.

Reply

james

10:28 am on Wednesday, November 23, 2011

How would you get more money in your check? Once again, look at all the people in the governors office getting paid and collecting a pension. That's a much bigger problem than sick time!

Reply
Comment_arrow

V

10:36 am on Wednesday, November 23, 2011

Golden Pinocchio Award goes to James for intentional lie!

N.J. municipalities face $825M in liability for workers' accumulated sick and vacation days: www.nj.com/news/index.ssf/2011/06/nj_municipalities_face_825_mil.html

Bronson

10:48 am on Wednesday, November 23, 2011

Eventually we will be paying more for the retired personel and have less of the actual working personell ... the system can't be sustained at this rate....we will have to cut hiring new people to work, in order to pay for the retired ones =less cops,fire fighters,teachers...

Reply

james

11:33 am on Wednesday, November 23, 2011

Thanks max! I guess ill be using a sick day friday

Reply

james

11:41 am on Wednesday, November 23, 2011

And speaking of lies, why are u all praising a governor who got elected on a lie?

Reply
Comment_arrow

V

12:18 pm on Wednesday, November 23, 2011

> And speaking of lies, why are u all praising a governor who got elected on a lie?

In case you failed to read my post properly, I did not praise Jon Corzine:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QyhTbBPeMsY

LV Mom

12:09 pm on Wednesday, November 23, 2011

Do you see what is going on here? When you watch the news and see people shooting their co-workers, bosses, or just plain anybody, you may want to think about this.

Reply

james

12:21 pm on Wednesday, November 23, 2011

Yea and what about lord christie?

Reply
Comment_arrow

V

12:34 pm on Wednesday, November 23, 2011

> Yea and what about lord christie?

Show some respect to your future President.

LV Mom

12:28 pm on Wednesday, November 23, 2011

Not as stupid as you might think.

Reply
Comment_arrow

V

12:49 pm on Wednesday, November 23, 2011

He is BIG, and his grudge with the unions will be even bigger by 2020. Imagine the size of the douche he'll apply to the public unions and their funds. I wouldn't put salary clawbacks outside the realm of possibility. Good advice: start stocking up Vaseline.

james

12:59 pm on Wednesday, November 23, 2011

He'll be a distant memory in 2020 and he is still obligated to make the pension payments he keeps neglecting. His grudge with unions isn't going to lower your taxes or help you in any way at all. And ill be collecting my pension that u think u pay for

Reply
Comment_arrow

V

2:22 pm on Wednesday, November 23, 2011

Chris Christie will be the President in 2020, though it is yet unclear whether it'll be his first or second term. By that time, your pension fund will likely be a thing of the past, so he'll work on clawing back your past salaries instead, while you contemplate your revenge standing in the hot soup line.

Comment_arrow

Bronson

2:27 pm on Wednesday, November 23, 2011

Corzine neglected the pension payments as did McSleezy....so don't blame Christie...thats all you guys know how to do Blame blame blame.....when someone actually starts doing something you call them names...NJ needs cleaning up and Unions are the first to go...

Kevin DeVine

11:30 am on Thursday, November 24, 2011

Mikey you hit the nail.While we fight the politicians get their perks and laugh at us.

Reply

anna Turner

8:17 am on Friday, November 25, 2011

If Christie wants to clean house why not start on top were the real money is. Thanks to the paper bring to light the PVSC scandal with all the relatives and friends cashing in on tax payers money. I'm sure that was common knowledge among the politicians. They don't like to step on each others toes.
Christie talks about putting a cap on superintendent pay. Great! But it should also apply to Charter schools. Why let someone get paid more and at the same time only has a couple of hundred kids under them? That is also tax money going out the window. Is that going to be the next scam that we are going to have to deal with. Who is starting these Charter Schools? I think I read somewhere that the VP brother is lobbing for them in FL? I was reading a charter school application filed by "Florida House speaker designate Will Weatherford and Anne Corcoran, the wife of future speaker-select Rep." was rejected. They both voted for Senate bill 736. I just know when money comes into play everyone will line up to cash in. They promise you everything you want to hear. In the end we are the losers. People in power will use their connections and be first in line.
Right now the people have the power. You can vote and also get on the school board if you don't like the way they are running it. The problem is most people don't even brother to vote for school elections. Once you give up your schools it's gone for good.

Reply

Richard Dean

5:37 pm on Saturday, November 26, 2011

When I began my muncipal career in Butler back in 1975, there was a clause in the labor agreement between the borough and the association (local union) setting up dollar amounts of compensation for percentages of unused sick time which were capped at $8,000 and $10,000 but not tens of thousands or hundreds of thousands. This was part of the bargaining process over the years that we accepted on condition of not receiving higher percentage raises. Many like myself retired getting only a small portion of the accumulated sick time in this manner not having to use 100, 200 and 300 sick days accumulated over the years.

Reply

La Quin

10:48 am on Tuesday, January 3, 2012

ok, let's be real.. most private sector jobs don't give disability anymore - so goodbye to that (we have to PAY for it)
next - most private sector jobs are 80 hours a week WITH work done on vacation - so a second job is even an option
next - most people in the private sector have HORRID pension plans - easiest way to cut someone's pay is to 'change' their pension plan / and increase out of pocket benefits cost.
..
the economy sucks... NJ is falling apart ... EVERYONE needs to take a hit.
--
and if ANYONE even mentions the whole 'teachers pay for stuff out of pocket' i'll scream.. i used to teach preschool and now i homeschool NEITHER qualifies me for a tax credit yet teachers get it.. trust me my homeschool out of pocket is WAY MORE then any teacher is laying out!

Reply

La Quin

10:48 am on Tuesday, January 3, 2012

oh, and as for private sector... WHAT SICK DAYS?

Reply

Leave a comment