What about Butler Bagels. I may like G&A's, but I also like Butler Bagels and they need my support more than G&A's. We need to support the businesses on Main Street in Butler and Bloomingdale.

G&A is the best!

I like Kinnelon Bagel the best.

Kinnelon Bagel is the Best!!!! Try the french toast bagels! :o)

Goldberg's bagels in Pompton Lakes blows them all out of the water

I have to say Kinnelon Bagels, especially when they come fresh out of the oven! Kinnelon Bagels all the way

If buying just bagels I would do so at Kinnelon Bagels. But when buying Bagel sandwiches, G&A is the absolute best. One of the best is their bacon tuna on a cinnamon raisin bagel.

Don't forget to review the business of your choice so try can win the contest!

G&A is the best. I would not bother going back to Kinnelon Bagel again they had ripped me off. I have never been to Butler bagel but i have heard they are good. I dp know my co workers and friends that go to G&A's a lot. And both Butler and G&A's bagels need are support.

My vote goes to G&A ! The bagels have the toppings on both sides.

What if one has more reviews but most are negative, does it still win?

G&A's history actually goes back about 20 years if not longer when they first opened as a 24/7 bagel deli in Newfoundland. About 1995 or 1996 G&A made the move 8 miles south to Butler into what had been Arrow Tire and previous to that a Shell station. I don't know if G&A still does but at the time it was supplying bagels to dozens of stores and other eateries on a daily basis.

I like the new bagel shop in Bloomingdale on Main Street. "D & D Bagel & Wraps".

It's the old Bobby's Bagel. They renovated & cleaned up the place and it's GREAT !! You should try it out !!

Butler Bagel outdoes them both.

I think it is so stupid to "pit" these two bagel places against each other. There are no less than 5 or 6 bagel stores in the area, why only two? Perhaps these are two of the editors favorites and that is why we are discussing because it is certainly not fair to IGNORE all of the rest. All you have here is employees and owners of every bagel place weighing in as if theyre someone else. What a waste of time.

Goldberg's is the best! And they too, have been around a long time! The owner comes from a family who has been in the bagel business since the 30's.

BUTLER BAGEL IS EXCELLENT

Kinnelon Bagel is by far my favorite ! They are quick and the bagels are always fresh.

I like G&A...and I'm not an employee or relative of anyone who works there.