patching...
Update: Two Found Dead in Kinnelon Home. Story Will Be Updated As More Information Becomes Available »
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

Thousands of Police, Firefighters Rally Against Layoffs, Benefits Plan

Union leaders say layoffs are making New Jersey less safe.

 

Thousands of unionized police and firefighters rallied at the statehouse Thursday against layoffs and Gov. Chris Christie's plan to have them contribute more to health and pension plans.

Throngs of public safety workers from across the state delivered a loud message to Christie, pointing to a 2009 campaign promise that police and firefighter pensions would not be changed.

New Jersey State Policemen’s Benevolent Association President Anthony Wieners has pointed to rising crime, coupled with police layoffs as putting state residents in danger. 

“The new normal in New Jersey is New Jersey has a crime problem," Wieners said, using a play on Christie's "new normal" budget message. "We are here to deliver a message in one loud, unified voice, that enough is enough."

State Senate President Stephen Sweeney, a Gloucester County Democrat and union organizer, also drew boos for backing Christie's plan to have workers pay 12 to 30 percent of their health care premiums.

Several Democratic lawmakers joined the rally in a sign of dissent from Sweeney. The crowd repeatedly yelled for Sweeney to address his support for Christie's plan.

"You have earned the right to negotiate your future," Senate Majority Leader Barbara Buono told the crowd.

Some elected officials said Christie was targeting the middle class while supporting the state's wealthy residents.

"The working people of this state need to get together and fight this class war,” said Assemblyman Gordon Johnson (D-Bergen). “We are now in a battle.”

While national media attention has focused on Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker's effort to eliminate most collective bargaining, Christie has said he "loves" collective bargaining. He has pledged to be tougher on public employee unions at the bargaining table.

Benefits must be limited to ensure the system's long-term fiscal health, Christie has argued. The state's pension system for public workers, including teachers, police officers and firefighters, is underfunded by $54 billion, according to the governor's office. 

Christie called the Thursday's event a "me first rally" at a press conference, but said he respected the state's first responders, NJ.com reported.

"I agree with him," said New Jersey Firefighters Mutual Benevolent Association President Bill Levin. "Every time the bell rings, every time shots are fired, you people say, me first, I go in first."

State troopers estimated around 7,000 people attended the rally, an agency spokesman said.  The crowd filled the block in front of the statehouse and overflowed into the park across the street. It was the second major public worker rally in Trenton in recent days. 

Janice Coviello

6:55 am on Friday, March 4, 2011

I am a contributing writer for the Patch and I think you did an excellent job on the video. It really narrowed the subject and the interviewees told the story black and white. Great job on this story - that's what the Patch is about - great press for the firefighters and police and the public gets the message without even attending the rally!

R. Swanson

9:42 am on Friday, March 4, 2011

We're supposed to cry for cops earning 6 figure salaries retiring after 20 years with full pension? I don't think so. As for that last out of touch cop who was interviewed: I don't care what you were "promised" in 1995 - we can't afford it. That promise was unrealistic and should never have been made. You've done very well for yourself I'm sure, even though you don't get stock options. Many folks who do have stock options find them to be virtually worthless today, while 401(k)s struggle to come back to where they were before the crash. We don't have pensions - only public employees do. You can retire as a young man, while because I chose not to feed at the public trough, I need to trudge to work every day until I'm 70+. Stop crying - collective bargaining is a scam designed to ripoff taxpayers. Public employee raises should be tied to the rate of inflation and job performance, and should not be granted by the very politicians the PBA helps to elect. The party's over - get to work.

Comment_arrow

Stunned Bunny

9:53 am on Friday, March 4, 2011

Sounds like you need to join a union!

Comment_arrow

n

4:56 pm on Friday, March 4, 2011

Sounds like someone received one to many traffic tickets.

V

10:26 am on Friday, March 4, 2011

If everyone joins the union, who'll be paying for their bloated salaries and benefits - Santa Claus? magic fairy? Obama and his Skittles-farting unicorns? We need to decertify and disband the public unions, and we need it NOW.

Comment_arrow

n

4:58 pm on Friday, March 4, 2011

Thanks Max, You just reminded me that Hitler felt the same way.

Comment_arrow

V

6:21 pm on Friday, March 4, 2011

Does everything you see or hear remind you of Hitler? Then you should know that Hitler's party was called "Socialist", just like the Democrats and their Clown-in-Chief.

Comment_arrow

n

11:00 am on Saturday, March 5, 2011

Hmm, what do you do for a living?

MadInNJ

10:34 am on Friday, March 4, 2011

Madison, NJ posted a roster of all its employees and their gross salaries for the past three years (see link below). The totals are eye-opening. And this doesn't include the cost of health care or pensions, which add at least another $30 - 40K per person. This puts the top people's total comp at almost $200K.

And now they are down in Trenton whining about paying for maybe 30% of just their health care coverage? And expecting sympathy from the general tax paying public? Wake up guys. The gravy train, which was leaking badly, has now split open.

http://gov.rosenet.org/uploads/25/comprankedrpt2010.pdf

Comment_arrow

V

10:44 am on Friday, March 4, 2011

OMG, thanks for posting it! The thing has to be all over the MSM... still waiting... nah, not likely. And that bunch of blood sucking leeches dares complaining about being underpaid?

CT

12:55 pm on Friday, March 4, 2011

I agree with Governor Christie -- we all must share in the sacrifice. True, we can't afford these pensions. But where is the sacrifice from the rich? Christie goes after middle class pensions and vetoes a bill that would have increased taxes on people earning more than a million dollars a year. People who earn their living through hedge funds do not pay income taxes on that money, but the much lower cap gains rate. Where is their sacrifice?

Comment_arrow

V

1:08 pm on Friday, March 4, 2011

I may disagree with the way hedge funds earn their money and get to pay taxes, but at least I'm not paying their salaries or their benefits out of my pocket - unlike those of public employees.

Comment_arrow

CT

1:10 pm on Friday, March 4, 2011

@Max -- the point is, if the superwealthy paid their fair share of taxes, your tax burden (assuming you are not ultra-wealthy) would go down.

Comment_arrow

MadInNJ

1:17 pm on Friday, March 4, 2011

First - What is their "Fair Share"? And how did your work out that number?

Second - If they are forced to pay what you think is their "Fair Share," how long do you think it will be before they relocate to a state with a more favorable tax climate (if I were you I would get ready to time this with a stop-watch that measures to the .0001 sec).

Third - When the legislature passed their Millionaires Tax last year it only generated enough money to goose the senior rebate program a bit. No money for property tax relief. No money to make the pension system any healthier. How much of a rate increase would be needed to fully fund all the public sector workers' wet dreams?

You might want to go back and reread the fable of "The Goose That Laid the Golden Eggs." Big words. Nice pictures. Right on Point.

Comment_arrow

V

1:19 pm on Friday, March 4, 2011

They already pay more than others. Fair share, you say? Just tell me who gets to decide how much is "fair", and whom to consider "ultra-wealthy".

Comment_arrow

CT

3:54 pm on Friday, March 4, 2011

Who gets to decide any tax rate, Max? I think it's pretty obvious that hedge fund managers should at least pay the same rate as their secretaries. Is that too hard?
And MadInNJ, -- do you believe that NJ's budget problems will be solved by simply going after union pensions and health care? Talk about geese laying golden eggs!
Also, if you raise tax rates -- even a little -- on the wealthy, where will they go? NY? CT? Taxes are high everywhere. It's like the criminals that built the housing bubble and then screamed that they would leave their companies if they didn't get their inflated bonuses. GO then...but where?

Comment_arrow

V

4:38 pm on Friday, March 4, 2011

Expropriating from the wealthy worked to the economies of Russia, Cuba, Byelorussia, South Africa and a few other countries I don't care to live in, didn't it?

Comment_arrow

CT

5:23 pm on Friday, March 4, 2011

Oh Max, you have GOT to be kidding. The differences between those countries and ours are so vast it simply makes your attempt at an analogy ludicrous.
The fact is the rich have seen their tax rates decline in the last 2 decades, the middle class and the poor have not been so lucky. We are broke. We need money. We can go after unions and their pensions, but that will not solve the problem in its entirety. The rich need to pay more. As is so often said these days, we have socialism for the rich and capitalism for everyone else.

Comment_arrow

V

6:23 pm on Friday, March 4, 2011

Yeah, the rich have to pay more. That's EXACTLY what Scott Walker is trying to achieve in Wisconsin. :)

Comment_arrow

n

11:56 pm on Friday, March 4, 2011

"Yeah, the rich have to pay more. That's EXACTLY what Scott Walker is trying to achieve in Wisconsin. :)"
No, the rich have people on the payroll to write the tax laws in their favor, so that they get to keep/hide/decrease their tax burden. While the middle class is stuck with a higher tax burden!

Comment_arrow

CT

7:23 am on Saturday, March 5, 2011

@n -- A few incoming Governors, in order to reduce the cost of their inaugurations, sold access to people willing to donate tens of thousands of dollars to their inaugurations. In other words, you got lunch with the new governor for $25K. I imagine there weren't too many middle class people taking them up on those offers.
@Max -- I've seen the stories on police chiefs who retire on inflated pensions and am just as disgusted as you. Fortunately, those are the extremes. Still, as a private employee, I see no problem having gov't workers contribute to their health care and pensions (The unions in WI agreed to that much, the issue now stands solely over collective bargaining). But I've yet to meet a rich teacher.

Dan Grant

12:55 pm on Friday, March 4, 2011

I can't talk of every town in NJ but the Police and Public employees in my town need 30 years for full Pension benifits and the Public employees need to be 55 to go on the pension. What I can't even begin to understand is the venom of people attacking Public Employees who have simply made a contract with their employers and expect their employers to live up to it. If you have refused to join a union or engage in collective bargaining or lost money on your 401ks because of Wall St. thak it up with A. your employer and B. the Wall St. Sharpie who rolled your pension down to nothing. The Employees of Montville Township are good people who do above and beyond the expectations of their job titles. How did they become the enemy of anyone.

Comment_arrow

V

1:05 pm on Friday, March 4, 2011

Thirty years for the full pension benefit (based on their largest salary no less, and with all the possible gimmicks applied to bloat it up towards the end), and they need to be 55 to retire, my @#$! Was it supposed to jerk a tear? It sure did - for my lost tax money!

And why are we still applying the private-business terms, like "bargain agreement", to transactions that have nothing to do with private business? Let's call them by their true name: extortion.

MadInNJ

1:11 pm on Friday, March 4, 2011

Dan - Being able to retire at 55 is a fabulous benefit. Try not to make it sound like working that "late" in life is such a burden. Second, given our current life span expectations, most of these retirees can expect to spend more time collecting a pension than they did working to get one!

And all of their gains haven't come at the bargaining table. A decade ago, in a fit of bi-partisan stupidity and a lot of pressure from the unions, the legislature and acting governor DonnyD upped everyone's pension by 10%! That legislative give-away should be rolled back ASAP.

And public employees keep moaning about being forced to live and die with Wall St (moving to 401ks), but right now we (the private sector employees) have our money in 401ks, and we are also expected to make up any shortfalls in the state's investments (also in the stock market)!

It's time we leveled the playing field and moved everyone out of defined benefit plans that have become black holes, and also require a meaningful contribution towards worker and retiree health care plans. This way people will start making intelligent choices about what plan they are in and how much they spend rather than just pulling a chair up to the all-you-can-eat lobster/caviar buffet table that's being 100% sponsored by the taxpayers on NJ.

Dan Grant

1:13 pm on Friday, March 4, 2011

Max you aren't in reality the Governor of Wisconsin are you? Why don't you post your full name and where you are from the better to gage your words of wisdom.

Comment_arrow

V

1:23 pm on Friday, March 4, 2011

As I explained to another troll on this board, I have kids in Montville school system. I have not a shadow of doubt that unionized teachers will find a way to punish my children.

Comment_arrow

R. Swanson

1:31 pm on Friday, March 4, 2011

Max and MadinNJ are spot on. Private sector workers not only need to fund their own retirement but those of public employees as well, and to a level of generosity that far exceeds anything that private sector workers will ever see. When public workers have to share in the cost, they will be more careful about which medical plan they choose. They should be moved to 401(k)s so when the stock market tanks, private sector workers are not left with the bill for a hole in the pension fund in addition to having to figure out how to rebuild their own retirement nest egg. Dan, until there is true pension and healtchare reform, public employees are the enemy.

Kevin Nedd

9:25 pm on Friday, March 4, 2011

You guys speak as if public sector employees sit around and collect their salaries and benefits without doing anything that adds value. These people educate your kids, provide emergency services when your house is on fire or you think someone is breaking into your house at 3 in the morning; last time I checked they plowed and maintained our roads; tested our drinking water, along with a whole host of other activities. None of these folks are getting rich as public employees. I am grateful for what they do and feel for them with regards to the petty and pathetic bitterness and jealously displayed thus far.

Louis C. Hochman

5:59 am on Saturday, March 5, 2011

As we've done with some other recent heated debates, we've removed several comments that included personal insults and open hostility. We ask you disagree and debate, but keep it civil -- refute one another's points, but don't attack one another as people. We'll remove comments that do so, and close the thread if they dominate the conversation.

Comment_arrow

Dan Grant

9:08 am on Saturday, March 5, 2011

Good policy. You should also have a policy of having to post under your real name. Anonymous posts often go over the top and those people should be held accountable. If you can't state you opinion without being identified then maybe your opinion isn't worth much. Max says that he is afraid his children would suffer. How silly is that. Anonymous posters talk of trolls and leeches because they can remain anonymous. A newspaper would not print a letter to the editor without a name attached to it so why is it any different in the new "newspaper" medium.

Comment_arrow

V

9:23 am on Saturday, March 5, 2011

I do agree that the "discussion" turned out a wee ugly and could use some cleansing, but forcing people to sign Internet posts is one good way to limit the debate to politicos and no-skin-in-the-game people. My fear that teachers may take revenge against my kids is based on actual precedents. Just look at those enlightened, mentally balanced people protesting in Wisconsin: http://www.moonbattery.com/madison_110219_bad_03.jpg

Kevin Nedd

10:30 am on Saturday, March 5, 2011

I am sure the educators in your town are far more professional than you give them credit.

Comment_arrow

V

11:18 am on Saturday, March 5, 2011

Most educators in my town (which happens to be Montville, NJ) are about par for a public-school teacher, which isn't TOO bad but definitely doesn't mean "the sharpest knife in the drawer". Some of them are admittedly good and professional, others are tolerable, and there's a bunch that serve as a proverbial spoonful of tar. The problem is, the union is mostly about the latter group, since others need "protection" like fish needs a bicycle.

Kevin Nedd

11:06 am on Saturday, March 5, 2011

"We know where the WMD is in Iraq..."

"I am hiking along the Appalachian trail..."

"obamacare will lead to death panels..."

"The last thing my administration will do is eliminate the property tax rebate program..."

"The President is a Muslim..."

In Washington Township, departmental spending was cut 20% last year..."

The GOP lies go on and on and on and on.

Comment_arrow

V

11:44 am on Saturday, March 5, 2011

I'll take "Obamacare will lead to death panels", since it's clearly true. As for "The President is a Muslim", who said that, besides me (not a Republican) and Obama himself (not a Republican either, last time I checked)?

By the way, how about:
"If you like your insurance, you can keep it."
"We've excluded lobbyists from policymaking jobs."
"Willia Ayers is just a guy in my neighborhood."

And the loveliest one, from 2006:
"The fact that we are here today to debate raising America’s debt limit is a sign of leadership failure. It is a sign that the U.S. Government can’t pay its own bills. It is a sign that we now depend on ongoing financial assistance from foreign countries to finance our Government’s reckless fiscal policies. … Increasing America’s debt weakens us domestically and internationally. Leadership means that ‘the buck stops here. Instead, Washington is shifting the burden of bad choices today onto the backs of our children and grandchildren. America has a debt problem and a failure of leadership. Americans deserve better."

Kevin Nedd

12:14 pm on Saturday, March 5, 2011

Max,

Try a little logic in your response next time. How can sometime be "clearly true" if it has yet to occur?

The president never said he is a Muslim. The interview where he misspoke and was corrected by Brian Williams doesn't cut it.

Kim Lehman, one of Iowa's 2 GOP reps on the Republican National Committee says the President is a Muslim. Try Google for more info.

Comment_arrow

V

12:39 pm on Saturday, March 5, 2011

I suggest we discuss facts and avoid personal insults. Cue the facts, courtesy of Goggle:

Egyptian Foreign Minister Abul Gheit said on the "Round Table Show" that he had had a one on one meeting with Obama who swore to him that he was a Moslem, the son of a Moslem father and step-son of Moslem step-father, that his half-brothers in Kenya were Moslems, and that he was loyal to the Moslem agenda. He asked that the Moslem world show patience. Obama promised that once he overcame some domestic American problems, he would show the Moslem world what he would do with Israel.

How did you feel when Obama canceled the National Prayer Day "to avoid offending other religions" but observed Islamic Prayer Day?

Kevin Nedd

1:01 pm on Saturday, March 5, 2011

First of all, the President did not cancel the "National Day of Prayer". This observance still stands. What the President chose to do last year was forego having an ecumenical service in the East Room of the White House, a practice that only began under the previous administration. The President has signed proclamations for "National Prayer Day" and will do so in the future.

Despite what Mr. Gheit claims, the President's word stands as he is the one who will be judged by Jesus with respect to his faith.

Dan Grant

1:02 pm on Saturday, March 5, 2011

Max or what ever your real name is your fears are just silly unless you feel your comments might embarrass your children. I spent 40 years active in the local political arena as an Active Democrat in a Republican Town and voiced plenty of opinions and positions in opposition to the local power. I have family here and raised two kids here who went through the public school system. I said what I believed and although the politcal opposition counld get a little nasty, I never was fearful about how it would effect anyone I said what I wanted to say and no didn't wher I stood. Man up Max. Isn't that the erm.

Dan Grant

1:08 pm on Saturday, March 5, 2011

Back to the topic. I worked with Montville Townships employees for 15 years. They are dedicated and hard working people who signed on to protect and serve and to work for the good of the Township. They were guaranteed a rate of compensation that included benefits in exchange for their work. They keep the Township operating and looking good as long as they have the tools to work with and most don't take retirement until well past the time they could. Police and paid Fire have a legitimate age at which physical limitations begin to creep in and it becomes important for both their safety and the publics that they retire. There is nothing wrong with that.

Comment_arrow

Kevin Nedd

1:37 pm on Saturday, March 5, 2011

Reminds me of the last GOP National Convention when Republicans were screaming "drill baby drill!" at the top of their lungs during Sarah Palin's speech.

Louis C. Hochman

2:07 pm on Saturday, March 5, 2011

We've deleted several more comments for reasons similar to those stated above, and this thread has is getting pretty far offtopic regularly. We'll now be closing comments on it.

The editor has closed comments for this article.