We like Ferati's Pizzeria, the tiny store at the corner of Boonton Avenue and High Street in downtown Butler. It actually has a heritage going back to at least the 1950's starting on Main Street as Casa Di Pizza then around 1968 became Tom's Pizza Inn which moved to the present location around 1970 followed by Steve's Villa from 1975 to the early 1980's then Buon Apetitio until it became Aroma in the early 2000's and now Ferati's.

Pizza King Is GREAT.
Good food, Good prices, Good atomsphere!!
Joey, Vinnie and the girls are freindly and courteous.
TRY IT......YOU'LL LIKE IT!!!!!

Hey I don't see Pizza Man on this list..we love their food!!

Positano's and Oakland Pizza. (how do they chose the list? just curious)

AJ's Pizza in Butler. Consistantly delicious food, friend Service/delivery & a great value.

Pizza 1 rocks, check it out.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-Yqzb4_SpiE

Pizza 1

We also enjoy Ferati's. Everytime I try something new, I'm never disappointed.

Pizza One!!!!!!! Love everything on their menu!!!! my favorite is the capri and white pizza with garlic!!!!!! Awesome!!!!!!

Where is Pizza Man? That's one I have not heard of.

Pizza1

Pizza man is in pompton plains . I just ate at pizza1 for the first time last night and it was awesome !! But we do like pizza king as well go food and great prices !!

Pizza 1 in Haskell for sure! Best pizza and food hands down!

Pizza 1. they are the best

we love pizza 1

Pizza 1 no doubt about it

We love Pizza 1 in Haskell. Its the best.

I don't see any mention of Coney Island Pizza in the above comments. It's a new place next to Rosemary and Sage. Thin crust--wood fired pizza, excellent caesar salad, clams, homemade tiramisu and canollis. Even the fresh mozzarella is homemade on the premises.

See what kind of food Pizza 1 has to offer...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=viEp34gStKI

thats easy pizza one in haskell

Pizza One is number one! i'm addicted to their food, vodka wrap, new yorker panini is sinfully good, and don't get me started on their pizza....you can't beat it!!!

Giovanni's Place (at the corner of Boonton Ave and Rt. 23 South) has truly authentic Italian food. In addition to traditional favorites and the finest pizzas, Giovanni's Daily Specials offer some of the most creative and delicious flavor combinations. A meal at Giovanni’s is a true taste of Sicily!

Pizza 1 is home to the "Pizza 1 Challenge". Only a few have accomplished this amazing feat of gut-stuffing glory! Joey Chestnut has NOTHING on the guys who have taken the challenge and won! The sandwich is called "The Fat Bastaad" and is a 14" sandwich in a toasted sub roll with Chicken Cutlet, Cheese Steak, onion rings, 2 different cheeses and topped off with Mayo! To win the challenge, one must eat THREE of these sandwiches in one sitting. This video is of one brave soul who attempted to take on the pizza world and the eating world by completing the challenge, check it out and see if he was able to climb the Mt. Everest of eating challenges! Oh.....and vote for Pizza 1 in this poll...Thanks so much!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y7lTEkPJypY

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O2c6zLYGvqg

Coney island - for sure, nothing compares to fresh brick oven pizza. try it you'll love it
.

Pizza One is very good pizza- one of the better ones, but it's ordinary pizza. Coney Island is in a whole different world and is incomparable. I agree with Lois. It depends what you like, but if you want a slice that will "stand up" on its on, with a crispy, thin crust, then it's Coney Island for sure. If you like the thicker pie with more stuff on it, then go to Pizza One, which is very good. The people at Coney Island are trying very hard and making some great customer relations.

coney island flat breads chicken sandwiches awsume.

Am I the only one that has eaten at both Coney Island Pizza and Pizza 1 in Haskell ???? Sure, Pizza 1 is good - and we are spoiled in NJ by being surrounded by great pizza.... but Coney Island Pizza is actually DIFFERENT and better - all ingredients and methods come from the source.... if you want something really good and different - treat yourself to Coney Island Pizza - it is above the rest....

...as Ann said, it's a different animal. By the way, Coney Island makes their own fresh mozzarella every day. That in itself is unusual. And their tiramisu and cannolis are also homemade by them.

Coney island pizza for the real deal. Have tried all aforementioned. Comet island proves to be the best by far.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VlLZQuj_LlA

But Pizza 1 makes the "Nonna" pie, check it out above.

This is kind of silly to b comparing oranges and apples. It's like saying the pork is good in one place but the shrimp is better in another. Neither of these places needs such vigorous promoting because they're both good in their own way.

I eat at Pizza 1 at least once a week and theres nothing like it. Staff is great and the food is even better. Try the Grilled Chicken Panini. AMAZING!!!

Pizza1 is the best around, no one comes close, and that's the bottom line. If you dont believe me try it for yourself

Pizza 1 is by far the best pizza place in this area. Food there is fresh and made to order and you can easily tell cause everything is delicious! they have a large variety of creative pies and its family owned and operated. they really take care of you and treat you like family at pizza 1!

WE LOVE PIZZA 1 CHICKEN MURPHY

PIZZA ONE >>>> EVERYTHING

OMG PIZZA ONE GIVES ME THE BUTTER FLIES, DANTE IS SOOO HOT

love pizza one, one of the best places to eat! great quality, great food, great service!

coney island pizza. best by far!

pizza1 is by far my first choice for lunch and dinner. monday nights are especially enjoyable being able to bring my children in to make their own pizzas. Great family owned business.

With Pizza 1's quality pizza and thier vast variety of other food, they are clearly the place to go to.

Pizza One knows what they're doing. Everything is excellent, from their pizza to salads, appetizers to desserts. All they need to do is hire some good looking girls to work the counter! :) A++

Just ordered a $30 stuffed pizza and got it for $10.99! Pizza 1 VIP texts, best deal in town!

I have to say that Pizza 1 is the best in the area. I own Hasbrouck Heights Pizza and I live in Pompton Lakes and when my kids want pizza I order it from Pizza 1. They have the best quality pizza and its the best tasting by far.

We love pizza1. we love thier salads,pizza,dinners and calzones

I work for Roma foods and im in 50 pizza shops daily, I have to say that pizza 1 is the best pizza I have ever tasted. and the wraps and panini sandwiches are phenomenal. The owner Dante is always present during business hours overseeing everything, he truly cares about his customers and employees and delivers a fantastic product consistently every day. As a salesman for Roma Foods, i hear about Pizza One everywhere i go talking to other businesses and pizza shops....bottom line is everyone is catching on to Pizza One and i'm impressed and so are other Pizza Shop owners who are constantly asking about what Pizza One is up to.

My ex- wife loves pizza one. so when i get to see the kids they only want pizza one. thank you pizza 1 for making my ex- wife and kids happy

Pizza 1 is the ONLY place that I will give my business to. They prepare the best dishes from a catering order to a relaxing night at home with a simple pizza and sandwiches. I drive 20 minutes to pick up my order, and it is well worth it! If you live in the area, you know you order from Pizza 1 at least 3 times a week! The best around...pure excellence! Thanks Pizza 1 for always giving us the best quality of food and service.

I have been living in Haskell for 3 years and everyone told me to try Pizza One. I tried it and have been a huge fan ever since. I have never been let down by service or food! Awesome!

Pizza 1 is the best my mom and I had it for lunch on Tuesday and loved the food. It was her first time there but the food was so fresh and the service was excellent. Ordered from them tonight and will keep going to Pizza 1!!!

Pizza 1 is definitely the best of the best. Their food is amazing and you can tell that they use high quality ingredients. Not to mention how fair their prices are. I won't order from any other pizzeria. Vote for Pizza 1 because they truly are the best!

Me and my family love pizza 1 the food is great. i always have them cater my partys and moe and dante are great guys. you can always see one of them there to help you out

I actually hate Pizza One.

i love pizza 1's BBQ chicken pie

I live in Riverdale and have been ordering from local pizzerias for many years until Pizza One opened up and i've been a loyal customer of theirs ever since. They have the best food hands down in the entire area. They really do stand out from all the other Italian restaurants in the area and really are number one, i would recommend them to anyone and everyone.

i had a stuffed meat lovers pie today and it was amazing. good work pizza 1

love pizza 1

pizza 1 all the way

all my family loves pizza1. very good food

pizza 1 is #1