Parents Submit Petition for First Grade Teacher

The petition has signatures from 70 families, according to resident Heather Turnbull.

About a half-dozen Chatham residents appeared at the Monday night Board of Education meeting to ask the board once again to hire an additional first grade teacher at .

Heather Turnbull, of Dale Drive in Chatham Township, spoke on behalf of those parents gathered and reiterated evidence that 20 students in a first grade class is "optimal" for early education and development.

With 113 first grade students currently registered at Southern Boulevard School for the fall, the number of students per classroom will be 22 or 23.

"The numbers remain essentially the same [from the last meeting," Turnbull said, with 113 registered students. "We're just please asking you to find a way to bring us that first grade teacher in the next year."

Dr. Michael LaSusa, the assistant superintendent, said the registration numbers continue to fluctuate. On Thursday, he said, they were down to 110 students in first grade; on Friday, enrollment rose to 113.

"I think that you'd be hardpressed to find an educator who doesn't support smaller class sizes, especially at the primary level," LaSusa said. "At the same time, we're looking at what the numbers have been historically. ... I think as a whole the [Personnel Committee] felt that we would continue to monitor how the enrollment went ... on a daily or weekly basis, but not yet commit to hiring a new teacher at this point."

LaSusa said that although the district has not advertised for a vacant first grade teaching position, they have already received numerous résumés from interested and qualified candidates. Rich Connors, the chairman of the personnel committee, said a classroom was available and the materials for that classroom were, for the most part, either available or could be easily purchased.

The 2011-12 budget, however, did not account for an additional first grade teacher at Southern Boulevard School and the district has already approved an additional fourth grade teacher at Lafayette Avenue School that was not accounted for in the budget.

Connors said that the personnel committee and LaSusa were monitoring the enrollment daily. "If the administration says that we need it, then we're going to do it," he said.

Turnbull said the petition contained the signatures of 70 families who support an additional first grade teacher at Southern Boulevard School. Copies of the petition were not available and Patch has not authenticated the names or the amount of signatures on the petition.

"We are victims of our own success," Turnbull said. "Young families move here with their young kids" so their children can attend Chatham schools, she said, and "I think the parent community would be disappointed to learn that the new norm is now ... 22, 23, 24 [students in a class]," she said.

The district's goal in this matter, Connors said, is to keep enrollment as close to 20 students per classroom as possible, with no more than 25 students in a classroom. "We're getting close to that critical number, which is why we're looking at it at a daily basis," Connors said.

At the present time, however, Connors said the enrollment numbers are not "compelling" enough to hire another teacher, especially when enrollment is still changing and when a teacher can be hired with relative ease and out of "a stack of résumés" closer to the start of school, if required.

The teaching position would be unfunded, so "we would have to find the money from another account or another source," Connors said. "The administration has told us that if need be, we can find the money."

Enrollment at Southern Boulevard continues to fluctuate, with seven students dropping out since the June 28 meeting and four more students coming in.

"We hear the parents loud and clear," Connors said.

Editor's note: A prior version of this story contained an error in Rich Connor's assessment of whether the enrollment numbers were compellling enough to hire another teacher. Chatham Patch apologizes to our readers for the error and has corrected it.

I'dRatherBeInMaui July 22, 2011 at 03:49 AM
You have all been so busy sniping at each other that you have strayed far off topic and I strongly suggest that you re-read this thread and take notice. I went to public schools ("Down South" at that!) until my graduate education at a Top 10 and highly competitive private MBA program in NYC. I have lived in Chatham for over 12 years and now have 2 children in Chatham schools (Middle). In comparing their elementary years to those of my own childhood I do not see any measurable advantage to the smaller class sizes they experienced in their elementary years than I did in my own (not that I took close count in either instance). Rather I think a student's success depends primarily upon their own personal drive and intellectual capacity in combination with the support they get from their family. As a divorced, professional (successful senior executive) Mom, I have never had the luxury of spare time, much less the inclination, to so closely monitor the size of my children's classes each year. Not to mention I have never heard of the ideal class size of 20 that you state, much less validate the model that your ideal number is derived from and as to how it correlates to the socio-economic/demographic metrics of those families served by the SBS district. In conclusion, before you, Ms. Turnbull, and your 70 friends, start demanding how the Chatham Shool district budgets it's limited funds, please research your facts and present a knowledgeable and convincing argument.
Captain Jack July 22, 2011 at 01:14 PM
Bravo ! I'd rather be in Maui too.
Jonathan Chatinover July 22, 2011 at 01:16 PM
It is interesting how you say that Ms. Turnbull and others "demanded" an extra teacher, when the article says that they "asked". In your post, you ask that Ms. Turnbull present her facts even though the article says that she presented their gathered evidence. You seem to discount the opinion of Dr. Lasusa, who is an expert in education and educational studies, who said that "I think that you'd be hardpressed to find an educator who doesn't support smaller class sizes, especially at the primary level". Do you have facts and/or studies that discount Dr. Lasusa's position? The Chatham School District target class size for first grade is 21. This has been set by prior Administrations and Boards of Education. Ms. Turnbull is simply asking that the Board and Administration keep to those targets.
Duncan Munchkin July 22, 2011 at 02:32 PM
Nothing against LaSusa, but I don't recognize his name as an "expert" in the field of education and educational studies. I can't find any papers he has written or seminars he might have lectured at. He doesn't even have his CV online. He is a teacher, turned principal, turned assistant super. Of course teachers prefer smaller classes...there is less work for them to do. Less kids, less papers, less everything. And teachers unions like smaller classes because it means more teachers. Unfortunately, the truth is that this country has invested in reduced class size (read as teachers) for the last 50 years and the academic/achievement gains from these investments has been negligible. There is plenty of evidence to support the opposite side of Ms. Turnbull's debate...start with Eric Hanushek...but you have to have an open mind. When you have a limited amount of money, class size is not really the most cost effective way of improving education.
Captain Jack July 22, 2011 at 07:37 PM
Mrs. Turnbull's tone could certainly be construed as demanding. Simply another example of some of the pushy entitled and righteous parents that seem to feel they know everything.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »