Butler Fire Department 26-28 Carey Ave, Butler, NJ07405 Butler Fire Department is a volunteer-only department that serves the Borough of Butler. The main department is located…More on Carey Avenue and several other stations are spread out throughout Butler. The current fire chief is Jim Neil. Keil Hook & Ladder Co., Kinney Hose Co. No. 1, and Peqquannock Engine & Hose Co. all operate out of the main firehouse of the Butler Fire Department.